Saturday, May 23, 2009

Sand vs. Soil for Propagation

I had a question posed to me through a comment on this blog that I've not really written about dealing with plant propagation: Why do I use sand instead of soil for cuttings?

Before I answer let me say that most (maybe about 95%) of my successful cuttings were done in sand alone with the rest in either in a sand and peat mix, regular soil, or water. There is no wrong way to root a cutting as long as it produces a healthy plant. If you like rooting cuttings in a jar of water then by all means go for it! There's more than one way to skin a cat (or so I've been told, I'd never do such a thing!)

I use sand for a several reasons:
  • It holds the cuttings upright (any potting medium except water should do this).
  • It drains well and keeps the cuttings from getting too moist.
  • Low fertility (no fertility really) means the energy of the plant goes into making roots and not foliage.
  • It is sterile since there is no organic matter for diseases and microbes to lurk.
  • The roots have an easy time penetrating the sand and put on some good initial growth.
  • It's cheap! (Perhaps the best reason of all.)
  • It's easily available at pretty much any hardware store.
Once the cuttings root they need to be transplanted into soil to gain the nutritional value of the soil. Plants that are easy to root (like forsythia, caryopteris, coleus, etc.) will do fine in soil but more difficult rooting specimens may simply rot in soil as opposed to vermiculite or sand as a medium. Peat can be used mixed together with either sand, perlit, or vermiculite and it maintains sterility due to its high acid content.

Why don't I use soil? Let's assume we are talking about garden soil and not soilless potting mixes you find in stores for seed starting. Those should be fine for any propagation purpose. Not all cuttings root easily in soil, but then again not all cuttings root easily. The difference in the sand vs. soil issue is the sterility of the soil. Here is what the Master Gardener Extension at Ohio State University had to say about the medium for cuttings:
"Insert treated cutting in a moist rooting medium. A suitable rooting medium is half perlite and half sphagnum peat moss. Any disinfested container with drainage is acceptable for use."
Here's what North Carolina State University had to say on the subject:
"The rooting medium should be sterile, low in fertility, and well-drained to provide sufficient aeration. It should also retain enough moisture so that watering does not have to be done too frequently. Materials commonly used are coarse sand, a mixture of one part peat and one part perlite (by volume), or one part peat and one part sand (by volume). Vermiculite by itself is not recommended, because it compacts and tends to hold too much moisture. Media should be watered while being used."
The problem with soil is that unpasteurized soil can contain bacteria. fungi (like damping off) and microbes that may harm a plant's growth or contain viruses that may spread to other plants. If it is too fertile it may encourage leaf growth (due to nitrogen) which you don't want at the initial stages of rooting, you want roots!

So in the end it comes down to personal preference. Many gardeners have methods of making potting mixes with different combinations of materials for different purposes and rooting plants is the same way. The sand works for me, but if a different rooting medium works for you then by all means use it. As long as the plant is healthy and happy in the end that's all that matters!

What soil mediums do you use for rooting, potting or seed starting? Do you have a favorite mix you use?

11 comments :

  1. I've not done much cutting propagation, but my mom always used sand and had good luck with it. She also dipped the tips in hormone powder.

    ~Faith

    ReplyDelete
  2. I will give the sand a try. I have several salvia greggii that I want to propagate as the colors are difficult to find. Maybe the cuttings will like sand better!

    Thanks for the education, as always.

    Cameron

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dave, most of the propagation I have done is into potting medium. I have limited success. Will try sand next time.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I've never done just sand, but can see where it would indeed be a better medium. I mix my own soil mixture with peat, topsoil, and perlite. Sometimes compost. For cuttings outside I've never had an issue with bacteria or fungi, but seedlings, now that's another story. You must for sure use sterile mixture then. I will most likely switch to sand here next time I take cuttings. It saves on mixing. I'd rather mix peat with sand than with good soil that I could use in pots. Another change you've helped me with. The first being to cut my lawn higher. It's working well.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Have a great Memorial weekend.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I just put it in gardening soil and have much success. I do however use the water method on several plants.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I usually use plain peat or vermiculite. I like the vermiculite because I just mix in into the garden when I'm finished.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Ok I have some plant propagation questions if you can help....
    I am trying to propagate a Weigela bush/shrub. I was told not to use old wood or new wood, so do you cut at both ends or leave the new wood on the end? I put some in water for now and they are pretty much branches and I wondered if I put some in sand where I should be cutting? If some maybe 10" peices cut on both ends would work. What do ya think? Is this confusing?

    ReplyDelete
  9. Shawn Ann,

    What they probably meant was semi-ripe wood. That means the wood has started to gain its darker more mature bark but still has some green. I wouldn't cut the green off the ends but wait until the wood looks right to take the cutting. A little brownish toward the bottom but still with green toward the top. Since you already have it cut take 4 node sections of what I just described from your cuttings. 1st year wood is usually the best wood for cuttings. I hope this helps, good luck!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I have used both straight sand and a mixture of peat/perlite successfully. I use propagation trays and intermittent mist and have come to the conclusion that even though the sand is much less expensive, the peat/perlite mixture weighs a considerable amount less when I move the cuttings out of the mist.

    Soil can carry diseases, bacteria, fungi, and even weed seeds that will inhibit your success. Soil will also retain too much moisture around the cuttings that will increase the chance of the stem rotting. Stick with sand or a peat/perlite mixture for a better success rate.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Good advice Dwayne! I would use the peat perlite mixture also if I were doing cuttings for mass production for the weight issue. Sand works great for me but I mostly do cuttings for my own person use and a few cuttings at a time means I don't have a weight problem. ;)

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for reading The Home Garden. Please feel free to comment on the posts, ask questions, offer suggestions, or just say hi!

I read every comment The Home Garden receives and appreciate the time you take to read about what I'm working on!

Dave

Advertising will be removed from comments as the administrator of this blog sees fit. If you wish to advertise please fill out a this contact form with your proposal.